Amazon profit-analytics tools, compared

SellerGuards vs Profit Cyclops

Two closely-matched profit tools that reconcile every Amazon fee and track your true cost of goods. This is an honest, side-by-side look at where each one is strongest — so you can pick the profit tool that fits how you actually run your business.

Last reviewed July 2026 · Profit Cyclops details from their public site; verify current pricing on each vendor's page.

SellerGuards

A precise profit-accounting platform for Amazon sellers. True FIFO lot-based cost of goods, a real month-by-month P&L, reimbursement recovery, product research, and a built-in finance module for your whole business — in a clean, fast interface. Built by a team with 10+ years in Amazon profit analytics.

Starts free FIFO cost of goods Built-in finance module US marketplace
Profit Cyclops

An established Amazon profit dashboard used by 50,000+ sellers. Real-time profit and P&L tracking, COGS management, stock alerts, PPC performance dashboards, a built-in reimbursement service, and native sync to accounting software — with coverage across many marketplaces plus Walmart and TikTok Shop.

From ~$19.99/mo Xero / QuickBooks / Sage Reimbursement service Many marketplaces

Feature-by-feature comparison

FeatureSellerGuardsProfit Cyclops
Real-time profit dashboardEvery Amazon fee broken outYes — reconciled per order from SP-APIYes — syncs roughly every 10 minutes
FIFO cost of goodsMargins on what you actually paidYes — purchase-lot level; updates as buy price changesCOGS tracking — COGS management in the dashboard
Month-by-month P&LFull financial statementYes — real P&L, every cost and marginYes — P&L reporting
Reimbursement recoveryMoney Amazon owes youYes — lost/damaged inventory trackingYes — built-in reimbursement service
Inventory & restock planningYes — FBA & FBM stock, restock alertsYes — stock alerts & forecasting
Built-in finance moduleNon-Amazon income, expenses, mileageYes — recurring entries, tax-ready, in one placeVia integration — push data to external accounting software
Accounting-software syncXero, QuickBooks, SageNot yet — books kept inside the finance moduleYes — native Xero / QuickBooks / Sage sync
PPC / ad analyticsYes — ad spend folded into true profitYes — PPC performance dashboards
Product research / sourcingYes — search, scan & calculate profit before you buyNo — post-purchase focus
Marketplace & channel coverageUS today — more rolling out automaticallyMany — multiple Amazon regions + Walmart, TikTok Shop
Account connectionOfficial Amazon SP-API (OAuth) — never stores your passwordAmazon API connection
Free trialStarts freeIntroductory first month (~$2.79), money-back guarantee
Starting priceFree, then a few dollars a month as you grow~$19.99–$39.99/mo, scaling by revenue tier

Profit Cyclops capabilities and pricing are summarized from their public website and may change. Always confirm current details on profitcyclops.com before deciding.

Which one should you choose?

Choose SellerGuards if…
  • You want cost-of-goods accuracy down to the individual purchase lot, so margins reflect exactly what each batch cost.
  • You'd rather keep your books in one place — a built-in finance module for non-Amazon income, expenses and mileage — than export to separate accounting software.
  • You want product research and reimbursement recovery alongside your profit analytics, and a clean, fast interface.
  • You sell on Amazon US and want to start free while you grow.
Choose Profit Cyclops if…
  • You sell across multiple Amazon regions today, or on Walmart and TikTok Shop, and need that coverage now.
  • You want your profit data to sync natively into Xero, QuickBooks or Sage.
  • You want a done-for-you reimbursement service built into the platform.
  • You prefer an established platform with a large existing user base.

Both tools offer a low-risk way to try them. The fastest way to decide is to connect your account to each and compare the numbers against your own settlement reports.

See your true profit in a couple of minutes

Connect once via Amazon's official SP-API. Every order is automatically costed from your real FIFO purchase lots, so you get accurate per-order profit and a live P&L — free to start.

Start Free →
Want the numbers before you commit? Try the free profit calculator →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between SellerGuards and Profit Cyclops?

Both are profit-analytics tools for Amazon sellers that reconcile every fee and track cost of goods, and the two are closely matched. Profit Cyclops is an established profit dashboard with wide marketplace coverage, a built-in reimbursement service, and native sync to accounting software like Xero, QuickBooks and Sage. SellerGuards focuses on precise profit accounting — true FIFO lot-based cost of goods, a real month-by-month P&L, reimbursement recovery, product research, and a built-in finance module for non-Amazon income and expenses — in a clean, fast interface. SellerGuards currently supports the US marketplace, with more rolling out.

Is SellerGuards cheaper than Profit Cyclops?

Both are priced for small and mid-size sellers. Profit Cyclops runs an introductory first month (around $2.79) and then scales by revenue tier — roughly $19.99/mo on Standard and $39.99/mo on Plus, higher for larger revenue. SellerGuards starts free and stays a few dollars a month as you grow. Compare the current numbers on each pricing page, since plans change over time.

Do both tools calculate cost of goods with FIFO?

Both track cost of goods. SellerGuards applies FIFO at the purchase-lot level, so each unit's COGS reflects the exact price you paid for that specific batch, and margins update automatically as your buy price changes across lots. Profit Cyclops offers COGS management within its profit dashboard. If lot-level FIFO precision matters to you, confirm the exact costing method on each vendor's current documentation.

Does SellerGuards integrate with QuickBooks or Xero like Profit Cyclops?

Not today. Profit Cyclops syncs with external accounting software such as Xero, QuickBooks and Sage. SellerGuards takes a different approach: instead of exporting to a separate accounting tool, it includes a built-in finance module where you log non-Amazon income, expenses and mileage alongside your Amazon P&L, so your books live in one place. If native accounting-software sync is essential to you, that is a point in Profit Cyclops's favor.

Which marketplaces does each tool support?

Profit Cyclops supports a wide range of Amazon marketplaces across North America, Europe and Asia-Pacific, plus Walmart and TikTok Shop. SellerGuards currently supports the US marketplace (Amazon.com), with more on the way — once you connect, new marketplaces switch on automatically as they roll out. If you sell across many regions or channels today, Profit Cyclops has broader coverage right now.